
Here's the lowdown
Only 17.7% of S&P 500 companies tie executive pay to carbon emissions, down from 30% in 2023.
The retreat sped up this year, with 40 fewer companies in the index using carbon measures in their compensation plans.
Verizon, Valero and Alcoa all removed or replaced climate-linked pay measures, but their filings point to different reasons.
The number fell fast
Corporate climate goals used to reach straight into the executive bonus pool. Now that connection is getting cut.
Only 17.7% of S&P 500 companies tie executive pay to carbon emissions. That is down from a 30% peak in 2023, according to data from The Conference Board and ESGAUGE. The count dropped by 40 companies this year alone.
The same pattern appears beyond the biggest public companies. Among the Russell 3000, the share using carbon measures fell from 10.3% in 2024 to 5.5% this year.
Those numbers remain above where they were five years ago. Still, the direction has clearly changed.
What a climate pay metric actually does
An incentive plan turns a company goal into part of an executive's paycheck. Hit the target and a bonus can rise. Miss it and the payout can fall.
That makes the metric more than a public promise. It gives the board a number to review and gives investors a way to see what management is being paid to prioritize.
Carbon measures can track emissions, energy use, low-carbon investment or progress toward a longer-term target. The hard part is matching a one-year or three-year pay plan with a goal that may not arrive until 2030 or 2035.
An executive rewarded today may be gone before that finish line. A board can also struggle to separate management's work from changes in energy prices, regulation or the economy.
Three companies rewrote the scorecard
Verizon had included climate performance in short-term incentive pay for 11 years. Its latest proxy filing says the company replaced its prior responsible-business measures with qualitative strategic and culture goals.
Those new goals cover areas such as customer trust, employees and productivity. Verizon kept the same weighting, but the carbon measure itself disappeared.
Valero used an energy transition modifier that could move part of an executive's incentive pay up or down by as much as 25%. The refiner's proxy filing says the measure helped push several lower-carbon fuel projects forward.
Valero did not renew it. The company said the original objectives were fulfilled by the end of 2024 and cited adverse conditions for low-carbon fuel investments.
Alcoa made a cleaner swap. Its proxy filing says a new strategic initiatives measure with a 20% weight replaced a carbon intensity measure that had carried a 30% weight.
One trend, three different explanations. That matters because removing a climate metric is not always the same as abandoning climate work.
Politics is only part of the story
Companies are making these changes as political and legal pressure around environmental, social and governance programs rises. Boards and large asset managers also face less pressure to make climate promises visible.
But incentive design is part of the pullback too. Long-term carbon goals can be awkward inside short-term pay plans, and a metric that sounds simple can be hard to measure fairly.
The sharper comparison is diversity and inclusion. In 2023, 58.1% of S&P 500 companies tied some executive pay to those measures. This year, only 10.4% did.
Carbon incentives have not vanished that quickly. They have moved backward enough, though, to show that boards are changing what appears on the scorecard.
The careful conclusion is not that companies stopped cutting emissions. The evidence shows that fewer executives have their pay tied directly to that work. Investors now have to look elsewhere in the filing to see who owns the goal, how progress is measured and what happens if the target is missed.
For more plain-English accounting and tax news, follow Ledger Lowdown.

